A new Competitive Evaluation of Smart House Motorisation Technologies in the World

The Wise Residence Automation industry in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) has been increasing at a quick pace considering that its dawn more than the final many many years. The marketplace is turning into much more and much more informed of the capabilities of having a complete automation system whether at the scale of individual residences, palaces, real estate developments, and lodges. Many developments in Dubai and Abu Dhabi have presently been finished with a pre-put in automation technique. Several developments in regions like Victory Heights, Arabian Ranches, Sports Metropolis, and Reem Island have also been constructed with infrastructure to help such technologies in the future.

In standard form, automation involves methods that management Lights, Appliances, HVAC, Curtains and Multimedia. The market place in the UAE has not only begun to understand the rewards in conditions of comfort and ease, protection, and luxury. But also in conditions of strength saving and escalating property benefit, hence all these realizations will carry on to direct to a booming marketplace in the UAE.

As automation is relatively of a new technology in the mainstream marketplace, 1 need to be aware of the countless amount of underlying technologies that connect and let for the communication among a person and the Gentle Dimming Systems or Air Conditioning Techniques. On the area, these technologies may appear to direct to the same performance, but in the again-conclude, they are various in probably catastrophic ways. This prospects us to the purpose why we commenced composing this article, that is, to lose light onto the pros and negatives of the various systems (irrespective of item or vendor) which are obtainable in the UAE marketplace nowadays.

Any automation method is composed of 2 large-degree factors, the controller, and the modules. The modules incorporate mild dimmers, relay switches, thermostats, motorized curtain manage systems, dispersed speakers..and many others. which are to be managed by the house operator. The controller, is the coronary heart of the technique from which indicators are sent to “Dim the lights” or “flip on the air conditioning”. The strategy of interaction between the controller and the modules are the Automation Interaction Technological innovation which we desire to tackle in this report. The method of communication can both be through wires or wi-fi and are usually in line with specific protocols or expectations of interaction. This report will investigate and compare KNX, X10, Zigbee, En-Ocean, and Z-wave.

The requirements for comparison which we will check out are the pursuing:

Dependability of Interaction: How trustworthy is the interaction among the Controller and the Modules? When a message is despatched to a module, the technique need to make certain the message’s arrival and affirmation of receipt. Scoring nicely in this criteria is quite crucial to make sure that even below situations of wired or wi-fi interference messages are resent until finally confirmed by the getting module. Not all protocols comply with this need.
Stability of Interaction: The protocol should assure that a 3rd celebration are not able to infiltrate an present method and work it with unauthorized obtain. The benefits of a hacker getting into a parking great deal of a resort and turning all its lights off is disastrous.
Characteristics and Capabilities: It is crucial that automation technologies go beyond just managing personal modules and have the functionality to combine with other methods most usually enjoyment since that is an location of substantial usage of any property operator. Example: Simple Integration with Multi-place Audio Methods, Multi-area multimedia distribution programs (Movies, Movies, Photos, Audio)…etc.
Investment Safety: It is crucial to make certain that set up Controller or Modules can be effortlessly replaced in the foreseeable future. Take into account getting set up a system that has some components fall short soon after 5 years, and at the identical time, the firm which installed it grew to become bankrupt. The house owner would be still left with no selection but to completely revamp the whole electrical program in the residence which would value more in time, labor, and equipment that what was at first paid out for the automation method. Having a system that is standardized means that any other organization can help it or exchange specific parts with distinct products, probably from various sellers, in buy to make sure continued procedure.
Interoperability: This conditions refers to the ability of the Controller to communicate to a number of Modules from different companies. This will ensure that a method is produced up with Lighting, HVAC, Curtains, Appliances, and Multimedia Control Modules are obtained from different manufacturers which are the very best or most specialized in these fields. This guarantees that a technique has the very best-in course Modules for each and every certain objective. It is not logical that the greatest maker of light dimmers is also the greatest maker of curtain handle programs, or audio programs. Some interaction protocols are shut or proprietary, hence forcing the buyer to purchase every little thing from a solitary maker. This conditions also overlaps with the Expenditure Defense Requirements since having an interoperable system will give potential flexibility to effortlessly exchange Modules even if the organization which set up them has closed down.

The remainder of this doc will handle each and every interaction engineering based on the earlier mentioned requirements.


KNX is an worldwide normal of communication normally set up in wired twisted pair environments. KNX was developed in 1990 and was made as a very strong protocol to be used in industrial automation applications. The protocols dependability cannot be questioned since it implements many OSI conversation layers and is quite complicated. KNX is also managed by the KNX affiliation and any organization typically spends hundreds of dirhams on their employees to go through training in get to comprehend the interior workings of the system. KNX is a sophisticated protocol by character, and was made long ahead of the “smart home” principle was born, therefore the components that has the functionality to assist the complexity of KNX is high-priced not only to engineer, but also to manufacture and hence the hopes for this technological innovation to turn into less expensive than its existing alternatives is futile.

www.ghv.de has and is a well-liked option for lodges since 2006 and has been deployed in many developments these kinds of as the Shangri-la in Dubai, Rotana Hotels in the Marina, Fairmont, Movenpick to title a couple of. KNX is also being specified by a lot of real estate consultants for main developments in the Abu Dhabi Reem Island and Yas Island.

Trustworthiness of Communication: Indeed
Safety of Communication: Of course
Value: No
Functions and Capabilities: No. KNX has been a lot more focused at the easy facility of automation and typically suits in hotel environments where customization and multimedia integration is not necessary.
Investment decision Protection: Indeed
Interoperability: Of course


X10 is an international open normal designed in 1975 by Pico Electronics of Scotland, in buy to let distant manage of home gadgets and appliances. It primarily employs the 220Vpower line wiring for sending messages in between the Controller and the Modules (Lighting, HVAC…etc).

X10 has only receyved some acceptance many a long time ago when automation technologies started getting introduced in the UAE. And was typically installed in modest villa undertaking then was gradually discontinued due to its trustworthiness issues.

Dependability of Interaction: No. Because it is vulnerable to interference from several resources like transformers, motors typically discovered in TVs, washing machines, enthusiasts…and so forth. Also, messages from Controller to Modules are never ever acknowledged so there is no 2-way conversation.
Protection of Conversation: No. If a 3rd celebration can faucet into the powerline of a house, messages can very easily be despatched to manage whatever the third party wishes.
Cost: Of course
Functions and Capabilities: Yes. This engineering can easily be integrated into Pc based systems and a lot of alternatives are offered to provide feature wealthy capabilities for household apps.
Investment Safety: Indeed
Interoperability: Sure


ZigBee is an open up wireless community conversation protocol dependent on the IEEE specification IEEE 802.15.4, which enables the Controller to connect with its Modules via Radio Frequency. The standard is a improvement of the ZigBee Alliance, which was established in the finish of 2002. It is an business alliance of a lot more than 230 enterprises who take up the globally improvement of this technological innovation. The 1st ZigBee products arrived on the industry in the commencing of 2005. Due to the fact Zigbee standardises only the decrease protocol levels (radio layer), the various producers have defined their own higher software program layers. As a end result ZigBee devices of distinct companies are not compatible with each and every other.

Dependability of Communication: Indeed. A wi-fi mesh community is created and guarantees multiple path routing to each module which interprets to prolonged reach, and high dependability in scenario of interference or even in scenario of in-path system failure.
Safety of Communication: No. Zigbee makes use of weak hashing algorithms and has been researched to be penetrable. Penetration is not simple but software program equipment this sort of as “Killerbee” exist and can let any man or woman with small Linux and scripting expertise to hack into an present Zigbee network.
Price tag: No
Functions and Abilities: Of course
Investment Security: Yes
Interoperability: No


EnOcean is a wi-fi radio frequency based, power harvesting technology utilised largely in creating automation techniques. It is not established out for international, European or national standardization even so, EnOcean GmbH is supplying its engineering and licenses for the patented functions under license inside of the EnOcean Alliance framework. The principle was created to enable batteryless sensors and switches for developing automation. Which is questionable in conditions of strength conserving because present options can eat as tiny as 500W per 60 storey tower in automation products.

EnOcean based systems have been mounted in some large initiatives this sort of as the Abu Dhabi Central Marketplace, the Dubai Monetary Center…and so forth.

Trustworthiness of Communication: No, En-Ocean does not offer you two-way communication between the Controller and its Modules. Also the Controller is at a star community with the Modules and there is no wireless meshing, this 1-to-1 signal mapping can substantially fail in moments of large interference.
Security of Conversation: Of course
Value: No, En-Ocean costs are much more aligned with KNX.
Functions and Abilities: No. Supported but not but noticed in the marketplace.
Expense Protection: Indeed
Interoperability: Sure


Between all the previously mentioned protocols, Z-wave ranks the greatest so considerably. The power of Z-wave lies in the large amount of distinct items from diverse companies as well as the very sturdy, 2-way, meshed, and secured wireless conversation. Z-wave chips also consume a 10mW at peak and are reduced price in contrast to all other options. Why? since Z-wave has been initially created for residential programs.

Z-wave is viewed as the next era of Sensible Home Technology and solution strains have began to emerge from huge players this kind of as Honeywell and Schneider Electrical. This technologies is not only attribute total, dependable and secure, but will be supplied at aggressive prices and expense security for tasks of any dimension starting up with person villas all the way to massive actual estate towers. As of right now, Z-wave has been deployed in several villas in the UAE at an personal scale. Z-wave is also starting up to make its way through numerous of the big tenders for developments through the Emirates.

Trustworthiness of Interaction: Sure
Protection of Conversation: Of course
Price tag: Indeed
Attributes and Abilities: Sure
Expenditure Defense: Of course
Interoperability: Sure

Shifra Intelligent Houses is a Sensible House options provider dependent out of the Dubai World wide web Town in the UAE. With a target on consumer expertise, Shifra Sensible Properties is making a revolution in the home automation market by bridging the entire world of dispersed media (songs, pictures, films and movies) with innovative manage methods for lights, appliances, curtains, protection, air conditioning, IR methods, and multi-space audio.

Leave a reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>